The government has recently stated that it is ready to reach an out of court settlement. According to Huseynov, the ECHR ruling on this case could be the first one on freedom of assembly specifically. “This is a sham settlement, as the government does not recognise that rights were violated,that the police who physically assaulted the journalists have not been brought to justice,” said Emin Huseynov.
One of the plaintiffs, director of Turan news agency Mehman Aliyev wants the issue to be settled in court. “Money is not the issue. The situation is getting worse in Azerbaijan. Freedom of assembly is still being violated,” he said. Aliyev believes that citizens’ constitutional rights to hold mass meetings, pickets or to protest in any other form have virtually been abolished. Anyone attending this kind of unsanctioned meeting is likely to face pressure from the police, the courts and others.
Two of the appelants: Azadlig newspaper editor-in-chief Ganimat Zahidov and independent commentator Shahvalad Chobanoglu agree with Aliyev: “If just one of the plaintiffs does not reach agreement with the government, the court will consider the appeal, which will very likely be granted,” Aliyev said.
The other 5 plaintiffs- Yeni Musavat newspaper editor-in-chief Rauf Arifogu and four employees of the same newspaper: Azer Aykhan, Etibar Seyidaga, Elshad Mammadli and Zabil Mugabiloglu did not attend the event.
Citing Article 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights, the journalists are demanding 5,000 euros each in compensation for psychological damage.