On 29 September, the Supreme Court of Azerbaijan returned Huseynov’s case to the Baku Court of Appeal, on the grounds that additional evidence needed to be taken into account in their judgment.
The court’s decision to validate rather than dismiss the punitive defamation case against Huseynov, lodged by those who abused him, fails to right a clear injustice. No one should be jailed for speaking out about how they’ve been physically abused by the agents of their government. It also contrasts sharply with the perfunctory dismissal of Huseynov’s own judicial complaint about his treatment.
The Supreme Court’s decision will further prolong his detention on these questionable charges, the underlying effect of which is not only punishing Huseynov, but also strongly chilling potential dissent and public protest by other Azerbaijani citizens.
While the government in Azerbaijan seems committed to continued punitive use of Azerbaijan’s judiciary, we are encouraged to see that international actors have begun to register their disapproval for this activity more strongly. We note for example the Council of Europe’s Committee of Ministers recent landmark opening of a legal infringement proceeding against Azerbaijan, prompted by its continued indifference to a 2014 verdict by the European Court for Human Rights that its detainment of political activist Illgar Mammadov is illegal.
We are calling on international actors to take a stand for Huseynov at several upcoming opportunities to make their voices heard, including this month’s Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, and the Human Rights dialogue between the European Union and Azerbaijan. Specifically, we:
Call on the Council of Europe’s Parliamentary Assembly to suspend Azerbaijan’s delegation from voting in its sessions until Mehman Huseynov and other wrongfully imprisoned journalists & freedom of expression activists are freed;
Call on representatives of the European Union to express their strong concern about Huseynov’s case and similar cases during the upcoming Human Rights dialogue between the European Union and Azerbaijan;
Call on UNESCO’s Director General to withdraw the honorary UNESCO ambassadorship of Mehriban Aliyeva, wife of president Illham Aliyev and recently appointed vice-president, or make it’s continued validity conditional on Mehman’s release and an end to politically motivated court cases.